The Lost Colony of Roanoke
In 1587 about 150 English settlers landed on Roanoke Island. Three years later they had vanished, leaving one word carved into a post.

In July 1587 about 150 men, women and boys settled on Roanoke Island, off what is now North Carolina, led by the artist John White. It was one of Sir Walter Raleigh's attempts to found an English colony in America.
On 18 August 1587 White's granddaughter, Virginia Dare, was born: the first English child born in the Americas. A few days later White sailed home for supplies. It was the last contact anyone had with the colonists.
The war with Spain and the Spanish Armada of 1588 kept him away. When he finally landed on Roanoke again, on 18 August 1590, the houses had been taken down and the site was enclosed by a palisade.
On a tree he found the letters CRO. On a post of the palisade, carved in capitals, was the word CROATOAN, the name of an island to the south and its people. Before he left, the colonists had agreed to carve a cross if they were forced to leave in distress. There was no cross. Storms stopped White from searching further, and he never learned what became of them.
Evidence
- John White's account of his 1590 return records the empty settlement, the letters CRO and the word CROATOAN.
- There was no distress cross, which White took as a sign the colonists had left without immediate danger.
- Settlers at Jamestown searched for the colonists in the early 1600s and found none.
What do you think happened?
You have the evidence. Stamp your verdict before you read ours.
Verdict
UNEXPLAINEDThe event is real and documented; its cause is unknown.
The colony and its disappearance are documented by the man who led it. What happened to the colonists is still unknown.
How readers voted
Theories vs evidence
They moved to Croatoan Island and joined the Native people there
POSSIBLEIt fits the carving, and later theories suggest the colonists merged with Native communities on the coast. No conclusive proof has been found.
They were all killed
UNPROVENJamestown's settlers came to believe this, but no remains or records confirm it.
Sources
- NCpedia (State Library of North Carolina): The Lost Colony
- National Park Service Historical Handbook No. 16: Fort Raleigh, White's 1590 return
Image credits
- William Ludwell Sheppard & William James Linton - CROATOAN, The Lost Colony (John White).jpg. Design by William Ludwell Sheppard, Engraving by William James Linton, No restrictions
Published 2026-10-25. Spotted an error? Email provenmysteries@gmail.com.